The Medicare Surcharge Most Retirees Don’t See Coming: How IRMAA Works and What You Can Do About It

Two Couples, Two Very Different Premium Notices

Two retired couples live a few streets apart. Both have similar lifestyles, similar savings, and similar monthly income. But when their Medicare premium notices arrive this January, one couple is paying the standard amount — and the other is paying nearly $100 more per month, per person.

guide mockup

“What will I owe in taxes when I retire… and how can I help cut that number down?”

Get our Arizona Tax Planning Guide so you can help keep more of what you’ve built.

GET THE FREE GUIDE

The difference has nothing to do with their health, their coverage choices, or even what they earn today. It traces back to a single large IRA withdrawal one couple made two years earlier. That withdrawal pushed their income above a threshold they didn't know existed — and now they're paying for it every month in higher Medicare premiums.

The culprit is called IRMAA, and if you're approaching retirement or already on Medicare, understanding how it works could help your household potentially avoid more than $2,300, or more, a year in unnecessary surcharges.

What Is IRMAA and Why Does It Catch So Many Retirees Off Guard?

IRMAA stands for Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount. It's a surcharge added on top of your standard Medicare Part B and Part D premiums if your income exceeds certain thresholds. Think of it as an extra charge that higher-income beneficiaries pay for the same Medicare coverage everyone else receives.

The part that surprises most retirees is the timing.

The Two-Year Look-Back

IRMAA isn't based on what you earn this year. It's based on your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) from two years ago. The Social Security Administration uses your tax return from two years prior to determine your current Medicare premiums. So if you're paying premiums in 2026, the SSA is looking at your 2024 tax return to decide whether you owe a surcharge.

This two-year look-back means that income decisions made years before Medicare begins — or years before you even realize the connection — can directly affect what you pay in premiums. A large Roth conversion at age 63, a one-time capital gain at 64, or an unusually high final year of salary can all ripple forward into higher Medicare costs two years later.

Why MAGI Is Not the Same as Taxable Income

The income measure Medicare uses — MAGI — is not the same number as the taxable income on your tax return. According to the Social Security Administration, your MAGI for IRMAA purposes is your adjusted gross income (AGI) plus tax-exempt interest income.

That "plus" matters more than most people realize. If you hold municipal bonds — a common choice for retirees seeking tax-free income — the interest from those bonds doesn't show up in your AGI and isn't subject to federal income tax. But it is added back into your MAGI for IRMAA purposes. A retiree can be in a comfortable income tax bracket while still triggering an IRMAA surcharge, simply because the two calculations use different definitions of income.

IRMAA Is a Cliff, Not a Bracket — and the Drop Is Steep

If you're familiar with how federal income tax brackets work, you might assume IRMAA operates the same way — that only the dollars above a threshold are subject to the higher rate. That assumption would be wrong, and it's an expensive mistake.

IRMAA uses a tiered system, but each tier works as a cliff. Cross the threshold by even one dollar, and the entire surcharge for that tier applies to every month of the year. There's no gradual phase-in. It's the kind of math that makes you want to double-check your tax projection — twice.

For 2026, the SSA's sliding scale table sets the standard Medicare Part B premium at $202.90 per person per month. For married couples filing jointly, the first IRMAA threshold begins at a MAGI above $218,000.

What Crossing a Threshold by Just One Dollar Actually Costs

Consider two married couples filing jointly:

  • Couple A has a 2024 MAGI of $218,000. They pay the standard Part B premium: $202.90 per person per month.
  • Couple B has a 2024 MAGI of $218,001 — one dollar more. Their Part B premium jumps to $284.10 per person per month, an increase of $81.20 per person per month. They also owe a Part D surcharge of $14.50 per person per month.

For Couple B, that single extra dollar of income triggers a combined annual surcharge of approximately $2,297 across both Part B and Part D for the household — ($81.20 + $14.50) × 2 people × 12 months.

That's not a marginal cost on the extra dollar. That's the full surcharge applied to every month of the year, for both spouses, because their income crossed the line. These thresholds are adjusted annually for inflation, so it's worth verifying the current figures at SSA.gov each year — but the cliff structure itself doesn't change.

If You're Retiring Soon: The SSA-44 Form Can Reset the Clock

The two-year look-back creates an obvious problem for people who retire in their early-to-mid 60s. Your final working years are often your highest-earning years — and under the standard look-back, those high-income years would set your Medicare premiums when you first enroll, even though your income has dropped dramatically.

Fortunately, there's a mechanism designed for exactly this situation.

The Social Security Administration recognizes a set of life-changing events that allow you to request a new IRMAA determination based on more recent income. According to the SSA's Program Operations Manual, qualifying events include retirement (work stoppage), work reduction, death of a spouse, divorce or annulment, marriage, and several others. The full list is documented on Form SSA-44.

Retirement itself — the simple act of stopping work — qualifies. If you retire at 64 after earning $280,000 in your final year, you don't have to accept that high-income year as the basis for your Medicare premiums at 66.

How to File and What to Expect

The process involves filing Form SSA-44 with the Social Security Administration. The form asks you to document the qualifying life event and provide an estimate of your current-year (or more recent) income. If your retirement income is now $90,000 — well below the first IRMAA threshold — the SSA may use that figure instead, potentially keeping your premiums at the standard rate.

One critical note: a Roth conversion or investment sale is not a qualifying life event. If a large conversion pushes your income above a threshold, you cannot use the SSA-44 to appeal that surcharge. The form is reserved for genuine life changes, not voluntary financial transactions. You can learn more about the appeal process on SSA.gov.

Already on Medicare? Shifting Distribution Timing May Help

For retirees already enrolled in Medicare, the two-year look-back creates a different kind of planning opportunity. If you can see that your current-year income is going to land just above an IRMAA threshold, there may be a way to bring next year's income below it — and potentially avoid the surcharge entirely.

The concept is straightforward: if you're going to take IRA distributions next year anyway, consider pulling some of them into this year instead. This increases your current-year MAGI but reduces next year's — and if next year's MAGI falls below the IRMAA threshold as a result, you may avoid the surcharge two years from now.

Here's a simplified example. A retired couple is on track to have $220,000 in MAGI this year — roughly $2,000 above the first IRMAA threshold for married filing jointly. They know they'll need about $4,000 per month from their IRA next year. If they pull forward four months of distributions — approximately $16,000 — into December of this year, their current-year MAGI rises to around $236,000 (still in the first IRMAA tier), but next year's MAGI may fall to approximately $204,000 — below the $218,000 threshold.

If their federal income tax bracket remains the same across both years, the income tax impact of shifting those distributions may be roughly neutral. But the potential IRMAA savings could be approximately $2,300 for the couple in the year the lower MAGI is used — though the actual impact depends on the couple's complete income picture, filing status, and applicable IRMAA tier. Arizona's flat state income tax rate may simplify the state-level side of this analysis compared to states with progressive brackets, but the federal bracket impact still needs careful modeling.

This strategy isn't automatic. It works best when you're only slightly above an IRMAA threshold, your income tax bracket is the same in both years, and you were going to take the distributions regardless — you're just shifting the timing. Before implementing this approach, we'd strongly recommend working with a professional who can model both years side by side. If you’d like to explore working with us you can connect with Sonmore Financial here to get started.

Years Before Medicare? Roth Conversions and Income Planning Can Reduce Long-Term IRMAA Exposure

If you're still in your late 50s or early 60s — years away from Medicare — you have the most powerful planning window of all. The decisions you make now about how and when to recognize income can shape your IRMAA exposure for the rest of retirement.

Why Age 63 Is the Critical Planning Horizon

Because of the two-year look-back, your income at age 63 is what Medicare will use to set your premiums at age 65 — your first year of eligibility. This means any large taxable event completed before age 63 won't affect your initial Medicare premiums. But anything that spikes your income at 63 or later could follow you into higher premiums.

How Roth Conversions May Reduce Future MAGI

Converting funds from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA is a taxable event — you pay income tax on the converted amount in the year of the conversion. But once the money is in a Roth, future withdrawals are generally excluded from MAGI entirely.

Consider a pre-retiree at age 61 who converts $50,000 from a traditional IRA to a Roth. They pay income tax on the conversion now, but that income hits their MAGI at age 61 — well before the look-back window opens at 63. More importantly, those funds are now in a Roth, where future distributions won't count toward MAGI. Over a 20- or 25-year retirement, this may meaningfully reduce the likelihood of crossing IRMAA thresholds, especially once Required Minimum Distributions from traditional accounts begin pushing income higher.  If these funds are needed for a future large purchase like a vehicle, home remodel, large trip, or medical expense those funds would be distributed from the Roth without impacting MAGI and without impacting your Medicare premium.

For Retirees 70½ and Older: Qualified Charitable Distributions

If you're already taking Required Minimum Distributions and charitably inclined, Qualified Charitable Distributions (QCDs) deserve a close look. A QCD allows you to direct up to $111,000 per year (2026 limit, indexed for inflation) from your traditional IRA directly to a qualified charity. The distribution satisfies your RMD but is excluded from your AGI — and therefore from your MAGI for IRMAA purposes.

For retirees whose RMDs are pushing them above an IRMAA threshold, QCDs may help reduce MAGI enough to drop below a cliff — while also fulfilling charitable giving goals. It's a strategy worth exploring with your financial advisor and tax professional.

Roth conversions and QCDs both involve real tax and planning considerations, and the right approach — if any — depends entirely on your current bracket, your projected future income, and your overall financial plan. Consider working with a qualified financial professional to determine whether these strategies are appropriate for your situation.

IRMAA Is Plannable — But Only If You Plan Ahead

IRMAA is one of retirement's most avoidable costs — but only if you know it's coming and act before the two-year look-back window closes. Whether you're filing the SSA-44 after a qualifying life event, timing IRA distributions to stay below a threshold, or converting to a Roth years before Medicare begins, each strategy requires careful coordination with your full income picture. Results will vary based on your individual financial situation, and no strategy can guarantee a specific outcome.

That's exactly the kind of multi-year, forward-looking planning a financial advisor is built to provide. If you'd like to review how IRMAA fits into your retirement income plan, we'd welcome the conversation. You can connect with Sonmore Financial here to get started.

References

  1. Social Security Administration. "HI 01101.020 IRMAA Sliding Scale Tables." SSA Program Operations Manual System (POMS). Updated December 2, 2025. https://secure.ssa.gov/poms.nsf/lnx/0601101020
  2. Social Security Administration. "Medicare Annual Verification Notices: Frequently Asked Questions." SSA Publication EN-05-10507. https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10507.pdf
  3. Kiplinger. "7 Ways to Plan Now to Save on Medicare IRMAA Surcharges Later." 2026. https://www.kiplinger.com/retirement/medicare/ways-to-plan-now-to-save-on-medicare-irmaa-surcharges-later
  4. Social Security Administration. "Request to Lower an Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount (IRMAA)." https://www.ssa.gov/medicare/lower-irmaa
  5. Social Security Administration. "Medicare Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount – Life-Changing Event (Form SSA-44)." Revised December 2025. https://www.ssa.gov/forms/ssa-44.pdf
  6. https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-drop/n-25-67.pdf

Disclosure

This content is for informational purposes only and should not be considered tax, legal, or financial advice. Consult a qualified financial professional before making any investment or tax-related decisions.

Advisory services are offered through Sonmore Financial LLC, an Investment Advisor in the State of Arizona. This material represents an assessment of the market environment at a specific point in time and is not intended to be a forecast of future events, or a guarantee of future results. This information should not be relied upon by the reader as research or investment advice regarding any funds or stocks in particular, nor should it be construed as a recommendation to purchase or sell a security. Past performance is no guarantee of future results. Investments will fluctuate and when redeemed may be worth more or less than when originally invested.

Talk to a Financial Advisor

Let’s start the conversation and put your wealth management plan into action. Click the button below to schedule a 20-minute call with Sonmore Financial.
START HERE

Similar Posts

  • Retiring Before Social Security Starts? Here’s How to Protect Your Income in the Gap Years

  • Mid-year Portfolio Check-In: Aligning Investments With Retirement Goals

  • Spring Financial Clean-Up: Managing Debt in Retirement

Here’s Your 2026 Tax Guide…

…Just tell us where to send it

We respect your privacy and promise to keep your information safe.

Do you know what your retirement tax bill looks like?

What tax-smart Arizona retirees do differently.

GET THE FREE GUIDE

guide mockup